The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has raised fresh doubts about the viability of crypto staking ETFs, casting uncertainty over the launch of the first funds tied to Ethereum (ETH) and Solana (SOL) staking. These concerns focus on whether such products legally qualify as exchange-traded funds (ETFs) under current U.S. securities law.
SEC Scrutinizes Ethereum and Solana Staking Funds
In a letter dated Friday, the SEC directly addressed ETF Opportunities Trust, expressing reservations over two proposed products: the REX-Osprey Ethereum ETF and the REX-Osprey Solana ETF. These funds, developed by REX Financial and Osprey Funds, aim to offer staking exposure—allowing investors to earn rewards from holding and locking their crypto assets to secure blockchain networks.
However, the SEC questioned whether the structure of these crypto staking ETFs meets the standards required under the Investment Company Act of 1940. Without fitting into this legal framework, such funds may be ineligible for listing on public exchanges.
The regulator also criticized the ETFs’ registration statements, suggesting they may be “potentially misleading” in describing their classification and structure. These unresolved issues have stalled progress toward market approval and may require significant revisions before any launch.
Legal Classification Remains Murky
At the core of the SEC’s concerns is the legal gray area surrounding crypto assets and staking mechanisms. The agency recently released guidance suggesting that staking participants do not necessarily need to register their activities. Yet, by raising objections to these ETFs, the SEC appears to be contradicting its own stance.
Greg Collett, general counsel at REX Financial, expressed optimism in comments to Bloomberg, saying, “We think we can satisfy the SEC on the investment company question, and we don’t intend to launch the funds until we do that.” Meanwhile, both REX Financial and Osprey Funds have declined to comment further.
If approved, the REX-Osprey products would become the first crypto staking ETFs tied to ETH and SOL, as well as the first spot Solana ETF. These milestones could represent a turning point for mainstream crypto exposure through regulated investment vehicles.
Commissioner Crenshaw Slams Regulatory Inconsistency
The debate over the legitimacy of crypto staking ETFs took another turn when SEC Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw publicly criticized the agency’s inconsistency. In a statement issued Saturday, Crenshaw challenged the notion that ETH and SOL can be considered securities in some cases but not in others.
She wrote: “We’ve seen staff statement after staff statement, pronouncing that all sorts of crypto assets are not securities. And yet, now we see no objection to the effectiveness of new exchange-traded funds that assert certain crypto assets—ETH and SOL—actually are securities.”
Crenshaw’s comments reflect broader tensions within the SEC over how to approach digital assets—a sector that continues to evolve faster than regulators can respond. Her pointed remarks question whether the Commission has developed a coherent legal framework for crypto ETFs and staking.
What This Means for Investors and the Market
For investors, the delay is a reminder of the regulatory risks involved in the crypto sector. While the potential of earning yield through crypto staking ETFs is appealing, the uncertain legal landscape could deter fund issuers and traditional financial institutions from diving in.
Moreover, the SEC’s stance may influence how other pending ETF applications—such as those tied to Bitcoin (CRYPTO:BTC), Ethereum (CRYPTO:ETH), or Solana (CRYPTO:SOL)—are evaluated in the months to come.
Despite these challenges, the appetite for crypto-linked ETFs continues to grow. Major players like BlackRock (NYSE:BLK), Fidelity, and Invesco are actively exploring new crypto products, including spot Bitcoin ETFs and futures-based offerings.
Whether or not staking products ultimately gain approval, it’s clear that the path forward will require legal clarity, consistent regulatory positions, and ongoing engagement between industry leaders and policymakers. Until then, crypto staking ETFs remain a promising—but still uncertain—frontier in digital asset investing.
Featured Image: Freepik © fabrikasimf
