The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has concluded a three-year investigation into Hiro Systems, a blockchain software developer formerly known as Blockstack, without recommending enforcement action. This decision marks a significant victory for the crypto industry, which has long grappled with regulatory scrutiny.
Background of the Investigation
Hiro Systems raised $70 million through token sales from 2017 to 2019. The SEC’s probe into Hiro Systems is part of the broader regulatory landscape that has often challenged the crypto sector. On Friday, a filing indicated that the SEC’s division of enforcement does not intend to pursue any enforcement actions against Hiro Systems. The letter stated, “Based on the information we have as of this date, we do not intend to recommend an enforcement action by the Commission against Hiro Systems PBC, formerly known as Blockstack PBC.”
However, the SEC included a standard caveat that this notice should not be interpreted as an exoneration or a guarantee that future actions will not arise from the investigation.
Hiro Systems and the Stacks Protocol
Hiro Systems is known for developing tools that enable developers to build applications on Stacks, a layer-2 blockchain designed to enhance Bitcoin. The Stacks protocol, spearheaded by crypto veteran Muneeb Ali, launched its first version along with its native token in 2018. Initially, the company treated the tokens as securities, conducting sales under the SEC’s Regulation A+, which permits limited public sales of securities without full registration. Other tokens were sold to accredited and international investors.
In January 2021, a new version of Stacks was launched featuring a new consensus mechanism called proof of transfer. Hiro Systems argued that the network had achieved full decentralization, and in an SEC filing that month, the company declared it was no longer providing essential managerial services to the Stacks Blockchain. Consequently, they claimed it was unnecessary to classify Stacks tokens as securities.
Despite these assertions, the SEC remained skeptical, and Hiro disclosed in September 2021 that it was responding to an SEC inquiry.
Conclusion of the Inquiry
The recent filing marks the end of the SEC’s investigation, relieving Hiro Systems from the prolonged regulatory scrutiny that had been looming over the company. This conclusion is particularly noteworthy following another significant development earlier in the week when the SEC ended its investigation into stablecoin issuer Paxos.
In a tweet following the release of the filing, Muneeb Ali clarified that the SEC’s probe encompassed the Stacks protocol in addition to the Hiro entity. Ali, who now serves as CEO of Trust Machines and remains a board member at Hiro, expressed relief at the investigation’s conclusion.
Implications for the Crypto Industry
The SEC dropping its investigation into Hiro Systems is a positive signal for the crypto industry, reflecting a potential shift in how regulatory bodies approach blockchain projects that achieve decentralization. The crypto sector has long been concerned about regulatory actions that could stifle innovation and growth. The conclusion of this investigation, along with the end of the probe into Paxos, could indicate a more nuanced understanding and acceptance of decentralized blockchain technologies by regulators.
Conclusion
The end of the SEC’s investigation into Hiro Systems marks a significant moment for the crypto industry, offering a reprieve from regulatory pressures. This development underscores the importance of achieving and demonstrating decentralization for blockchain projects to navigate regulatory challenges successfully. As the industry continues to evolve, clear and consistent regulatory frameworks will be crucial in fostering innovation while ensuring compliance.
Featured Image: Freepik
